Medical necessity definition
A service is "medically necessary" when it is needed to diagnose or treat an illness, injury, condition, or its symptoms, and it meets accepted standards of medicine. Most commercial plans use wording close to this, and add that the service must be clinically appropriate in type, frequency, setting, and duration — and not primarily for convenience or more costly than an equally effective alternative.
What it does NOT mean
It is not a judgment of whether you personally need care. The reviewer compares the documentation your provider submitted against written policy criteria. If the chart is incomplete, the decision can go against you even when the care is genuinely needed — which is why many denials are reversed once the missing records are sent.
How insurers decide what is medically necessary
Reviewers rarely make a decision from scratch. They check the request against:
- The insurer's own published medical policy or clinical policy bulletin for that service.
- Industry-wide rulebooks — the two most common are MCG (from a company called Milliman) and InterQual. Think of them as checklists: for thousands of tests, surgeries, and hospital stays, they spell out what proof insurers will accept that a service is truly needed. Most insurers buy one of these instead of writing every rule from scratch.
- For Medicare: the "reasonable and necessary" standard, plus National and Local Coverage Determinations (NCDs/LCDs).
- Specialty society guidelines and published clinical evidence.
- Your records: diagnosis codes, symptoms, how long they have lasted, and treatments already tried.
Examples of medical necessity criteria
Criteria differ by insurer and service, but common patterns include:
- Lumbar spine MRI: often requires about 6 weeks of failed conservative treatment (physical therapy, medication) unless red-flag symptoms are present.
- Knee replacement: documented arthritis on imaging, functional limitation, and failure of non-surgical care.
- Brand-name or specialty drugs: step therapy — trying a preferred, lower-cost drug first.
- Sleep studies: specific symptoms and a screening score before an in-lab study is approved.
Common reasons for "not medically necessary" denials
In practice, most denials fall into a few buckets:
- Missing documentation — exam notes, imaging, or proof of prior treatment were not sent.
- Conservative treatment not tried or not documented for long enough.
- Diagnosis codes that do not match the policy's covered indications.
- Wrong setting — for example, inpatient when outpatient would meet criteria.
- The service is classified as investigational for that condition.
What to ask your provider
Ask your provider's office to confirm which diagnosis codes were sent, whether prior conservative treatment is documented in the chart, and whether the prior authorization request included the most recent exam notes and imaging. Ask whether a peer-to-peer review (a call between your doctor and the insurer's medical director) is available before a formal appeal.
Letter of medical necessity
A letter of medical necessity (LMN) is written by your clinician to explain why the service is needed for you specifically. The strongest letters quote the insurer's own policy criteria and answer each one point by point with dates, test results, and prior treatments — rather than simply restating the diagnosis.
If the request is denied: how to appeal
Under the Affordable Care Act, most plans must offer an internal appeal and an independent external review. Typical steps:
- Request the denial reason and the exact policy criteria in writing.
- File an internal appeal — usually within 180 days of the denial notice.
- Include an LMN and any missing records. Ask for an expedited (urgent) review if waiting could seriously harm your health; those are generally decided within 72 hours.
- If the internal appeal is upheld, request external review by an independent organization. Your state insurance department, or the U.S. Department of Labor for self-funded employer plans, can help.